New study on nurses' representation on governing boards

Dr. David Keepnews, PhD, RN, JD, FAAN, and I just published a study of "Health Professionals' Representation on Governing Board of Health Care Organizations in New York City" in the Journal of Urban Health, an interprofessional journal sponsored by the New York Academy of Medicine.

The study was based upon the premise that the fiduciary responsibility of governing boards now goes beyond financial health. It includes the quality and safety of health care provided by the organization. But trustees who hold appointments because of their potential to bring in donations to the institution may have little grounding in how to promote the quality and safety of the care provided by their organizations.

We surveyed all hospitals, home care agencies, federally qualified health centers, and a sample of nursing homes in New York City. Physicians served on over 20% over hospital governing boards, while nurses served on less than 6% and no other health professionals appeared to be trustees. Home care agencies and nursing homes fared a bit better, however.

The IOM report challenges nurses and society to ensure that we are represented in leadership positions in health care, including governing boards. This study confirms national data on hospitals showing that nurses are underrepresented on these boards. Our study also included a qualitative component that ascertained the barriers and facilitators to getting such appointments.

The DOI for the paper is (DOI) 10.1007/s11524-012-9772-9. It was published online first and will appear in a future issue of the hard copy of the journal. Here is a link but it's time-limited and you'll probably need to go through your library to access it for free: http://www.springerlink.com/openurl.asp?genre=article&id=doi:10.1007/s11...

Diana J. Mason, PhD, RN, FAAN

by Diana Mason | December 10, 2012

Tags: data, education, capacity-building, interprofessional-collaboration, leadership, practice, new-york

Andrea Brassard

Congratulations Diana on a fabulous paper that I hope will be widely disseminated. Powerful quotation on page 8. "The worldview of nursing differentiates itself from the world view of other health professionals. They're very interesting and overlapping but the worldview of nursing is about how people live with whatever state of health they happen to be in at any one point...Nurse meet people where they are, in the social context of where they live, and that worldview...needs to be brought to the policy table because it's a little different from the 'interventionist, let me cure' view of some, or the 'how do you fit the social system' view of the nutritionists, physical therapist, and so on...And then there's a practical side of what nurses bring. Nurses-whether it's a survivor skill or taught - know something about how to make things happen. Sometimes they make do by going around things; sometimes they make it happen by doing it through the policy chain. But these sort of practical things can be very helpful on a board." http://campaignforaction.org/resource/new-study-nurses-representation-governing-boards-new-york-city-0
Posted on: December 12, 2012, 2:41 pm

Jasmine Samra

"The IOM report challenges nurses and society to ensure that we are represented in leadership positions in health care, including governing boards." The leadership course in baccalaureate programs is where the seeds are planted for students to begin to consider the importance of nurses representing the field. Since nursing practice is directly involved with the decisions of governing bodies, would it be appropriate to interweave leadership with every course in nursing school? I acknowledge the difficulty to edit course objectives, yet another field that needs reform.
Posted on: January 29, 2013, 10:50 am

Jasmine Samra

Hi Andrea, great reply! I was curious to see the content of the link you posted, but the page couldn't be found, could you repost the link?
Posted on: January 29, 2013, 10:54 am

Andrea Brassard

Posted on: January 30, 2013, 7:24 am

Victoria Vinton

Jasmine - I agree with you. Leadership should "interweave" within the entire curriculum. Leadership is an important skill to hone for all nurses to better advocate for patients. Leadership education can no longer be considered necessary only for administrators. Nebraska, in conjunction with the SIP grant is working to address leadership and make it part of the competency-based education model across all 20 schools in the state.
Posted on: January 30, 2013, 10:12 am

Pat Farmer

Leadership takes many forms in nursing, and it would be ideal to weave the content throughout the curriculum. However, there are issues which concern me. One is that it becomes challenging to show where in the curriculum the content is located. This may sound like a minor point, but our accrediting bodies need to be able to verify that critical content is present, and this becomes more complex when it is not centralized in a course. A related issue is that I have seen "interwoven content" become a thin veil for content being diminished or lost. As an example, in days gone by most programs had a course in geriatric care, a course in culturally competent care, sometimes one in history of nursing, etc. Each had dedicated faculty, time allotted, objectives, etc. Then most programs eliminated those courses and threaded the content through the curriculum. Faculty teaching other courses were expected to pick up that content, and that was done with varying degrees of success. One last twist to this issue is that as we work to align curriculum across institutions, we will have to assure that all these topics are interwoven in a manner that allows seamless progression.
Posted on: February 11, 2013, 2:44 pm

Pat Farmer

Diana, it is great to see some data on this important topic. A challenge in less formalized assessment of nursing presence within organizations is that they are often not identified as nurses in their title. I find that when an agency or institution lists their board members or directors, physicians are listed as "Jane Doe, MD" . Nurses, OTOH are simply listed as "Jane Doe". One has to seek a bio to find out that they are, in fact, nurses.
Posted on: February 11, 2013, 2:54 pm

Lisa Sundean

Pat, I can attest to your comment regarding listing nursing credentials on governing boards. I formerly sat on a hospital board and while I always signed in as RN, the minutes never reflected the credential. In contrast, the MDs were always listed with proper credentials. I currently sit on a board QI committee and the same is true. Another issue is that many nurses drop the RN credential as they climb the executive ladder because the credential is seen as a barrier to professional executive development. These are the nurses who will most likely end up on boards. After giving an evidence-based presentation to a hospital board nominating committee on the value of nurses on boards, I was treated with pleasantries, at best. No action was taken. Even after follow up 4 months later, I was told there were other priorities and they had not considered the presentation any further at that point. I do think it's a battle worth fighting to be sure the best interests of patients are represented in the board room - and who better to do it but the nurses who represent the front line of care?
Posted on: April 21, 2013, 5:03 pm

Iris Yuen

Lisa, that is such an unfortunate experience yet not surprising. The voices of nurses are often overridden by physicians. The title of RN holds so much more responsibilities than it seems. However, it is so unfair how with the huge amount of responsibility comes with it no power. This post is a great reminder to let nurses know they have to step up to the plate and represent their patients and the scope of nursing by fighting to get that position in governing boards and voicing their opinions.
Posted on: December 3, 2013, 12:09 pm

Susannah Williams

I agree with you all. Although I’m not a nurse, I’m beginning to understand the value of the nurse’s worldview as I experience it as a nursing student. They seem to be uniquely qualified to address quality of care and safety issues, as it is their main focus. Nurses, as patient advocates, can share patient’s concerns, giving more power to an individual’s voice. I’m glad that the paucity of nurse representation on health care governing boards has been identified and that it has created a need to increase those numbers. I feel that we’ll all benefit from it in the end. Susannah Williams Accelerated BSN Student Rutgers School of Nursing
Posted on: March 29, 2014, 6:19 am

Emily Clarke

As a current nursing student, I have been educated on the important roles a nurse plays throughout a health care organization, with emphasis on the role as patient advocate. I believe it is important that we have equal representation as members of an organization and speak up for our own needs to the larger healthcare community in order to provide optimal care. In regards to any business, including hospitals, the evidence shows a strong correlation between a healthy working environment and leadership at all levels of an organization. But I believe in order to foster healthy working conditions, the different entities need to work together at all levels. Physicians, nurses, social workers, pharmacy, dietitians, etc. all have to respect one another for their expertise in that specific field. I believe the idea of mutual respect should be fostered at the earliest possible time- during education. I think nursing schools and medical schools should integrate a course to foster interdisciplinary care. We should learn to work together now to provide care as a team so we can understand each other's roles. If we can learn to work together at the basic level, we can grow together as future leaders. I hope to see more nurses equally represented at the governing level. Emily Clarke Rutgers School of Nursing Resources: Sherman, R., & Pross, E. (2010). Growing Future Nurse Leaders to Build and Sustain Healthy Work Environments at the Unit Level. Retrieved June 22, 2014, from http://nursingworld.org/MainMenuCategories/ANAMarketplace/ANAPeriodicals/OJIN/TableofContents/Vol152010/No1Jan2010/Growing-Nurse-Leaders.html
Posted on: June 22, 2014, 12:02 pm

Jennifer Marlette

I appreciate the opinions and ideas offered to increase the level of nurses represented on governing boards. I agree that patient care and outcomes would be improved by having the voice of nurses involved at that level. So many boards can be out of touch with the actual day to day practice and of patient care. Having nurses involved in that level would bring a new perspective, hold higher accountability for safety and good outcomes. Nurses are the driving force behind healthcare and having that position and voice would only benefit all involved.
Posted on: October 26, 2014, 7:41 am

 

Community Guidelines

Be Transparent: Always identify yourself.

Be Responsible: Take ownership of your comments and uploads; respect the opinions of others.

Be Non-Partisan: Reserve all lobbying and/or political endorsements for your personal social network.

Be Responsive: Make your participation a dialogue and not a monologue.

Be Aware: Graphic, obscene, explicit or racial comments or submissions; comments that are abusive, hateful or intended to defame anyone or any organization; third party solicitations or advertisements; comments that suggest or encourage illegal activity, are subject to be removed.

View the full Community Guidelines

learn

about progress in your state